It's like whoah, if you girls were all in one room with Craig, there would be riots.

so I'm asking, who likes the music, and just find Craig and the gang normal looking?

I fell in love with the music before I did the band

Same here.

The fact that they're good looking is just a big plus!

I had no idea what they looked like when I first heard their music.
But no, I dont think theres a female in general who wouldnt find craig even slightly good looking.

Actually i spotted Craig first in pics someone posted once on some White Stripes forum back in Feb/March of 2004. And this was before i heard their music. Thought he was gorgeous as fuk. Had to find out if i liked the music too. ....at first i wasnt quite sure.. ...but then the more songs i heard, the more i loved....and here i am.


And i may have to disagree with ya there Bus Boy. No one man or woman can appeal to everyone! Humanly impossible! So that said, i'm sure there are tons of folks to whom Craig would not appeal in the least. No way is he everyones type. Hard to believe they'd think he was ugly tho, i dont think that would be possible! ..but even then, you never know.

but he's so pretty

exactly!

^ Damn strait!

I fell in love with the music first, and Craig second. So I would love them just as much if Craig wasn't as beautiful as he is.

Heard music first, saw the videos later . and when i'm boring the shit out of my friends i do so using only the music. At the end i add he's hot.

Girls, do you think we'd kill eachother if in the same room?

I didn't really find Craig that attractive when i first started listening. I just kind of grew into it, if that's how i should describe it. Oh i know tons of girls that would NOT find Craig good looking. The non-fans though. The ones that are in to Chad Michael Murray, etc. (certainly not saying he's not attractive). Ugh, this one girl i had classes with used to nag on me for the craig pictures i had on my notebooks and stuff. She said he was hideous, and to be quite honest, i really don't know how that's possible.

That's one messed up person. And i'm not saying this because I find Craig really hot (it's just my taste, you'd se I pretty much really like only guys like Craig...the hair, boyish face and so one). But if someone is good looking, he's good looking.

oh, i just remember that my friend (VERY SPECIFIC TASTE) said that craig looked cute. I think she saw winning days on the tv

god, i hope i'm making any sense

Well I guess I could say that I fell in love with Craig's self portrait on WD first - since that's why I bought the album - I didn't know it was a pic of a band member though - I just thought it was a cool cover . Anyway - I listened to the CD before I flipped through the book and fell in love straight away . By the time my diskman was halfway through TV Pro I was back in the CD shop looking for more Vines album. I fell in love with Craig... or at least thought "woah! He's cute " when I got home and saw what he looked like in the CD booklets .

That's the best question ever! He's not really my thing, but I think there's no denying that Craig is gorgeous. Supremely talented musically and artistically as well. Yay Craig!

the first song i heard was winning days and i loved it but i didnt find them dishy until i saw get free (odd that i saw the more recent one first i know).

i actualy didnt really know if he was that hot when i started listening to them, but one day i decieded to watch thier music videos and look and picrures and i was very very pleasently suprised....but i swear he could be ugly and i would still love thier music, its just a very good bonus

I think that, yes, there are some girls who don't find him atractive at all...but just girls that aren't itto the band....all of us want to marry him -hehehe- and find him the hottest person in the world, but that's coz we -kind of- know him...we feel we know him, coz of his music or ...i don't know but, we just think he's the cutest person ever...even my boyfriend wanna marry him..hehe, yeah -and yes, his a fan too-!!...we will marry him some day.

Well, I think I'm the only one one the forum that doesn't find Craig sexually attractive. Yeah he's good looking I'll agree with you all there but I could never again think he's hot! I used to before I met him and then, I don't know what you'd call it, anti-chemistry?, he's just felt like my little brother ever since! I love him so much but in a brother/sister way! Now Ryan on the other hand!!!! Hot as hell with the heating turned up full blast on a summer's day!!

Nah, you're not. I like the music, pure and simple. I've never been into the Vines because of their looks. Craig is a cute guy but I'm definitely not into him sexually.

Well, I think that girls have a tendancy to be attracted to musicians and a significant factor is the music of course. It just makes them so attractive ...I mean, if I knew nothing about Craig, never heard his music and just saw him randomly I would think he's good looking of course, but I wouldn't be drawn to him like this . Yes, we all know I have a bit of a crush on Craig. Just a bit

Ha! there are PLENTY of bands whose music i adore. ...but it certainly dont make me the band attractive to me.

maybe, the more you listen to the song words, the more attractive they become..say if a singer writes about something cute like love, you would think..yeah hes sensitive..i like sensitive, and the crush grows from there.

Really?

I guess i cant relate to that. I must be the only one.
Cause if the singer aint attractive to begin with, i dont care HOW moving the music is. I aint all of a sudden gonna find the singer attractive.


Am i the only one who's like that?

hmm..possibly....

I thought so!

Yep, that could be part of it . Or just an admiration, I don't know.

Carolyn: well, they do have to be cute to start with ...but I think it's the music and interivews or whatever that really makes me all ridiculous over a guy in a band.

at first i thought Jon Fratelli was a bit...well he was no craig nicholls, but now ive listened to more of their songs, he has a very happy and energetic aura and i find myself thinking...awwww isnt he lovely

I would like to think so.



Well that's because we get to see a little of how they're like. Obviously we dont KNOW them, but it helps more then just a photo.

i'm a really sad person but the reason i bought my first vines album (highly evolved) was because I saw the clip of Ride and thought Craig was a hotty. But now it's about the music, I get little crushes like that all the time.

.

Me.

Ha! You lie!

I never lie. It's against my religion.

You're winking blinking alot

I never blink. It's against my religion.

Does anyone find him attractive when he made vision valley? because i think he look fucking gross

OH.MY.GOD.

Yes, yes, yes. He was so fucking sexy. He's sexy no matter what. (: Yum, yum.

I don't care about appearance

Talent is more important

Yeah I get like that.
I'm not attracted to Craig. I mean I think he looks alright but I've got many intense crushes on other singers/musicians.
I get more attracted to peoples personality and quirks. The quirkier the better.

Y'all is crazy. Bb is a fine dime.

Honey, all girls have different celebrity crushes

Some have the hots for RPattz, some have the hots for Daniel RADcliffe and some have the hots for Craggie

I.DON'T.UNDERSTAND.

I'm one of those Dan Radcliffe fans, but it's more to do with me being proud of him because he has dyspraxia (a coordination impairment in the brain) and he became an actor to overcome his issues.
I got bad coordination as well.

me too

I have Aspergers and I'm pretty clumsy with holding things and walking.

I use to have a crush on Daniel Radcliffe when I was 11 up until 15.

I do too. I wrote about it in my introduction post.
I used to get really nervous about using chopsticks in front of people, but now I'm just like 'eh it's just cause of Asperger's...whatever.'
The speaking thing I'm not very good at.
I look like I'm 11 to 15.

Oh and I think in time Craig will become much more attractive to me.

I'm okay with chopsticks

I do have trouble speaking and I look like I'm 16 even though I just turned 18

And there are alot of forum members on here that also have AS as well

http://thevines.forumsunlimited.com/index.php?showtopic=4941

Wow, where has this forum been all my life?

Welcome to the forum

Do you post at Wrong Planet too? That's where I like to rant about the unfair NT world, lol. That and my blog.