Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Last Vines Song Standing IV
The Vines Message Board > The Vines > The Vines General Discussion
Pages: 1, 2
wonkytooth
One more round until we head into the finals...in Round 4, you're to decide which Vines song is your favorite from their b-sides, unreleased demos, and - yeah - one song off a soundtrack. wink.gif Songs that later appeared on albums (aka 'Sunchild') are not included, nor are b-sides that were simply live songs or the 'Don't Listen...' instrumental that backed the limited edition oz single (since so few have heard it). Which one of these will come out victorious? That's for you to decide. IPB Image


The winning songs for Round 1 'Highly Evolved' were:
1. Mary Jane
2. 1969
3. Homesick (tie)
3. In the Jungle (tie)

The winning songs for Round 2 'Winning Days' were:
1. Winning Days
2. Autumn Shade II
3. Amnesia

The winning songs for Round 3 'Vision Valley' were:
1. Spaceship
2. Vision Valley
3. Nothin's Comin'


rideintothesun
this is hard ....um either landslide, down at the club, drown the baptists, or ms. jackson
Rusty
MS JACKSON BETTER WIN OR ELSE.


Although I have a soft spot for Down at the Club tongue.gif
Cigarettes and Song
Down at the Club for sure because I love Ms Jackson and I'm Only Sleeping but they are covers so I'd like to vote for a Vines original song and so that's the best demo I think.
wonkytooth
for me it was between 'giveX3', 'watch the world,' and 'don't go.'

in the end, i icon12.gif 'giveX3' a smidgen more than the others.
Rusty
QUOTE(2110 @ May 3 2006, 01:03 PM) *

Down at the Club for sure because I love Ms Jackson and I'm Only Sleeping but they are covers so I'd like to vote for a Vines original song and so that's the best demo I think.

Uh...I get your point, but Ms Jackson is such a great cover!
Just think...to make a masterpiece out of such a piece of sh***
Only The Vines could have done that!!!

It's like, the greatest cover EVER!!!


I hope it wins pray.gif

Cigarettes and Song
Ahhhh yes that's true. I heard the Vines version first and then when I heard the original i was like icon8.gif it was so bad especially in comparison with beautiful Vines version.
wonkytooth
aw, you guys, i like the outkast version too! what's cool about the vines cover is that most cover songs are paint-by-numbers of the original, but craig took the original and really made it his own, unique song.
Kid A
for me it's either don't go or hot leather i can't decide
Clelia
for me it was between hot Leather, Down At The Club and I'm Only Sleeping.
Ended up voting for Down At The Club
Brooklyn Girl
The Outkast version is hardly a piece of shit! mad.gif rolleyes.gif

Anyway I am stuck between GUGOGI. Ms. Jackson and Don't Go. I may have to go with Don't Go but Ms. Jackson is great too. Grrr...I can't decide. mad.gif
sad.gif
omgwtf
Take a Sunday
Rusty



QUOTE(Kid A @ May 3 2006, 01:33 PM) *

for me it's either don't go or hot leather i can't decide

Oh please Rajiv, please vote for Ms Jackson! ohmy.gif
It's such a great song!!!
QUOTE(Vinny @ May 3 2006, 01:10 PM) *

Just think...to make a masterpiece out of such a piece of sh***
Only The Vines could have done that!!!

It's like, the greatest cover EVER!!!
I hope it wins pray.gif

QUOTE(2110 @ May 3 2006, 01:27 PM) *

Ahhhh yes that's true. I heard the Vines version first and then when I heard the original i was like icon8.gif it was so bad especially in comparison with beautiful Vines version.


Please...

pray.gif
Cigarettes and Song
OH crap i forgot about Don't Go. That's totally the best oops next time i'll read through the whole list mad.gif

QUOTE(wonkytooth @ May 3 2006, 11:01 PM) *

aw, you guys, i like the outkast version too! what's cool about the vines cover is that most cover songs are paint-by-numbers of the original, but craig took the original and really made it his own, unique song.


Yeah that's really awesome. I was expecting the Outkast version to be really similar to the cover but it was completely different. Maybe I'd like it if I heard it before The Vines cover wub.gif It's just so much better in my opinion.
Brooklyn Girl
Holy hell, Dan. That's some avatar you got there! ph34r.gif
omgwtf
QUOTE(Brooklyn Girl @ May 3 2006, 02:51 PM) *

Holy hell, Dan. That's some avatar you got there! ph34r.gif

biggrin.gif
Kid A
QUOTE(Vinny @ May 3 2006, 01:45 PM) *

Oh please Rajiv, please vote for Ms Jackson! ohmy.gif
It's such a great song!!!
Please...

pray.gif

stop brainwashing me, vi
wonkytooth
QUOTE(Vinny @ May 3 2006, 09:45 AM) *

Oh please Rajiv, please vote for Ms Jackson! ohmy.gif
It's such a great song!!!
Please...
pray.gif


vin, if you sleep with rajiv to get the vote, i'm disqualifying you both. mad.gif


tongue.gif
Kid A
QUOTE(wonkytooth @ May 3 2006, 02:06 PM) *

vin, if you sleep with rajiv to get the vote, i'm disqualifying you both. mad.gif
tongue.gif

hey, thats a thought

::votes ms jackson::

vi?
Thomhatesmusic
i can't decide oO
SaraGriffiths
i think give up, give out, give in ..its the best song....I love it sooooooooo much
And the voice from Craig in that lyric.... wub.gif
Rusty
QUOTE(wonkytooth @ May 3 2006, 02:06 PM) *

vin, if you sleep with rajiv to get the vote, i'm disqualifying you both. mad.gif
tongue.gif

ohmy.gif

QUOTE(Kid A @ May 3 2006, 02:15 PM) *

hey, thats a thought

::votes ms jackson::

vi?

mellow.gif

If you voted for Ms Jackson, I'm really grateful, but that's all

So don't you get any ideas, kiddo tongue.gif
Vine ♠ Child
This one is easy!


Don't Go!!! biggrin.gif wub.gif
wonkytooth
QUOTE(Vinechild @ May 3 2006, 10:55 AM) *

This one is easy!
Don't Go!!! biggrin.gif wub.gif


i knew you'd vote that! i almost went ahead and voted it for ya! laugh.gif

we know each other well, c. hug.gif
Vine ♠ Child
QUOTE(wonkytooth @ May 3 2006, 08:01 AM) *

i knew you'd vote that! i almost went ahead and voted it for ya! laugh.gif

we know each other well, c. hug.gif

biggrin.gif hug.gif
allie9609
Blues Riff wub.gif
omgwtf
QUOTE(allie9609 @ May 3 2006, 04:10 PM) *

Blues Riff wub.gif

mellow.gif mellow.gif mellow.gif
mary_jane83
Miss jackson !!!!

but drown the baptiste and watch the world ... give up give out give in, and Landslide is fuckin' brilliant ! biggrin.gif
littlemissjoey
I don't believe I've heard Blues Riff. mellow.gif sad.gif

I went with Give Up Give Out Give In - thought I hadn't heard it before but in fact realised it was a song which I referred to as Softspoken cos I never knew the title - but I also love Hot Leather. It's just so raw sounding and awesome. cool.gif
mary_jane83
QUOTE(littlemissjoey @ May 3 2006, 05:10 PM) *

I don't believe I've heard Blues Riff. mellow.gif sad.gif

But why do you all think that no one will choose 'Blues Riff' ? blink.gif
SickleCell
Landsliiiiiiiiiide
Brooklyn Girl
I settled for Don't Go but it was close.
gypseyrou2005
This one is the worst for me pinch.gif

either

Blues Riff
Miss Jackson
Give Up, Give Out, Give In

or

Dont Go


I just dont know


Ah hell.. I went with Dont Go wub.gif
Endanger
Give up give out give in is amazing but watch the world is jes beautiful!
gypseyrou2005
What, no votes for From The Land? laugh.gif Come on, that intro is killer
Maxwell Demon
none of my picks made it so far

anyways I say Take a Sunday
LockedInAFreezer
Take a Sunday. Bad quality recording, but it's an awesome song.
LucyNicholls

Miss Jackson tongue.gif
mia
i always thought i would go straight for down at the club, but seeing all of them, made it hader, i realy love drown the baptists...i went for down at the club though, is such a great song
Ava Adore
FROM THE LAND!!!!!
littlemissjoey
QUOTE(Mary_Jane83 @ May 4 2006, 04:47 AM) *

But why do you all think that no one will choose 'Blues Riff' ? blink.gif


huh.gif I'm not sure what you mean... unsure.gif
shellz
ohh its so hard! i love all the b-sides and demos. but i gootttta vote MS JACKSON, because often i listen to that song on repeat for hours when im feeling down and it cheers me up hug.gif
the_likely_lad
Take A Sunday. I hope they record that one day.
wonkytooth
looks like ms. jackson has this one locked - vin must be whoring herself hard tongue.gif - but the race for spots #2 and #3 is tight. i'm happy to see 'take a sunday' doing so well!
Rusty
QUOTE(wonkytooth @ May 4 2006, 11:00 AM) *

looks like ms. jackson has this one locked - vin must be whoring herself hard tongue.gif - but the race for spots #2 and #3 is tight.

I'm doing no such thing unsure.gif tongue.gif
Brooklyn Girl
Wasn't Hot Leather a single release?
wonkytooth
yeah, 'hot leather' was a single. i'm still needing the green vinyl copy of it too. dry.gif
Brooklyn Girl
I don't have any of the really old releases, sadly. I guess there's always eBay.
mary_jane83
QUOTE(littlemissjoey @ May 4 2006, 07:28 AM) *

huh.gif I'm not sure what you mean... unsure.gif

Oh, okay ! i meant seems to be that everybody on this thread think that blues riff is not a good choice ! and i wondered why !

btw sorry but you know if you don't really understand that's because i'm french and my english level is not really good enough ! wink.gif
Minnesoter_Matinee
Take a Sunday thumbsup.gif

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.