It IS really hard to pick, but I have to say Kurt.

Hmmm... probably Kurt, but I like Craig's songs and music more. I voted for Craig anyway, even though its not strictly true since the poll isn't 'who do you like more', but 'who's the best song writer'. Oh well, I'm biased.

Craig. I'm not a big fan of Nirvana.

how does someone become better than someone at songwriting.. thats weird

i think its in all of our best interests to never compare the Vines with Nirvana ever again.

Kurt, no competition there.

I put Kurt.
I dont see why everyone is comparing nirvana and the vines, i dont think they're very alike.

Kurt Cobain.

Well, if you compare Britney Spears' lyrics to those of The Libertines, I have the slightest idea you might not find it so weird anymore.

Anyway, I picked Craig. I prefer his lyrics, to be quite honest. I'm not really into Nirvana. I do like some of the lyrics, but I just don't prefer them.

God, imagine picking The Libertines as one of the best examples of songwriting. Surely it would hurt?

Kurt Cobain, obviously. Obviously.

I never said they were the best. Not at all.

I'm just picking them as an example. They have some deep lyrics. Besides, anything compared to Ms. Spears' lyrics can be seen as deep.

What would you give as an example of very good lyrics, then?

I like the lyrics of 'countryyard', seriously.

I'd say Can't Stand Me Now. It's not a lyric that has been written by some lyrical genius, but it's so deep and just genuine. I consider that as good, too.

So would I, actually. Not so much the lyrics but the courageousness (or just courage?) of singing such things as a duet. Well done them.

'good old days'....

Kurt Cobain changed music forever. Even though Craig is a good song writer it is hard to top Nirvana.

I think Craig's lyrics are more artistic.

I would have to totally agree

Kurt

esspecially think about what a huge influence on Craig, so if there hadnt bee a Kurt, there probably wouldnt be a Craig now

man this is hard as shit... but on this one id have to say...cocaine and drug influence is the best song writers between them... they both make beautiful poems...

I can't decide, but isn't Craig Nicholls so hot?

Please. Don't.

Craig hot you say. Well I'm a guy (and not gay) but I do think some guys are hot judging by their voice.Like Trent Reznor or Craig Nicholls.

haha we talk about lyrics and somebody just had to bring up how hot craig is..

Most of craigs lyrics dont make sense.. they are good but i prefer to actually understand what a person is singing about.. no offense to anyone of course.

Kurt

I'm faithful...Craig !

Craig

he's much more versatile

Craig is hot bt Kurts not to bad eather,..

...like in your sig Vinny....

Well, I don't think Kurt would have been able to play the guitar in this position

No it's impossible ...
Craig is the best !

Kurt is winning tho'...
I think more Craig Nicholls-obsessed crazy maniacs should vote in this poll

Yes you're right Vinny !
U and I ...that's all ?

shame isn't it?

but maybe they will come...

thank you TalkNerdy for bumping this thread

(The last post before that was on March 12...the club wasn't organized yet)

I hope ...

VINES FANS OF THE WORLD, UNITE!!!

Yeah !

haha.. what have i done!!!

i like them both...but i picked craig because his writing isn't quite as depressing as kurts....plus, i just feel i can relate to what he has to say more than kurt.

outtahere
sm

They are both genius song writers. I know a lot of people are going to disagree with me on this, but i think craigs writing style would be a little different if nirvana didn't exist.

Oh, sorry. I didn't see that before i posted.

I guess it's Kurt though it's hard

mr. cobain

NO

Mr Nicholls !

YESSS!!!

I wish I could vote twice...AT LEAST!

I still don't know... I never concentrate on the lyrics...

de de de of the month!





hahahahahahahahahha.








what a(nother) stupid thread.

poor grammar'd(?)